
TL;DR
Renew if your term is ending and you only need a new rate: there's no prepayment penalty at maturity, and an uninsured straight switch to another federally regulated lender skips the stress test. Refinance if you need to borrow against your equity, consolidate debt or change your amortization. Before the term ends, a refinance usually means a prepayment penalty, so price that first.
Key Takeaways
Renewing keeps your mortgage balance and sets a new rate and term when your current one ends. Refinancing replaces the mortgage so you can borrow against your equity, consolidate debt or change the amortization, and doing it before the term ends usually costs a prepayment penalty. For most Alberta homeowners, the choice depends on when your term ends and whether you need money out of the house.
Below I've compared the two side by side, shown how a penalty changes the maths, and set out which option fits which situation. The penalty formulas themselves are in my guide to calculating a mortgage penalty.
Renewal wins on cost and simplicity when your term is ending and you only want a better rate. Refinancing wins when you need to change the loan itself: take equity out, roll in other debt, buy out a co-owner or reset the amortization. It costs more to set up, so it has to earn that cost back.
| Factor | Renewal | Refinancing |
|---|---|---|
| When | At the end of your term | At maturity, or mid-term if the numbers work |
| Prepayment penalty | None at maturity | Usually, if you break a closed term early |
| Balance | Stays the same | Can go up, usually to no more than 80% of your home's value |
| Amortization | Carries on from where it was | Can be extended or shortened |
| Stress test | Not expected on an uninsured straight switch between federally regulated lenders | Expect it, since the lender underwrites a new mortgage |
| Costs | Possible discharge, transfer or appraisal fees if you switch lenders | Appraisal and legal costs, any penalty, and the Alberta Land Titles fee to register the new mortgage |
Sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada on renewing a mortgage and borrowing against home equity, OSFI on the minimum qualifying rate, and the Government of Alberta Land Titles fee schedule ($50 plus $5 for every $5,000 of the principal, effective October 1, 2026).
Renewal is also the cheapest time to change lenders. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says a lender must send your renewal statement at least 21 days before your term ends, and it suggests you start shopping a few months earlier rather than waiting for that letter. You can also negotiate with your current lender for a lower rate than the one it quotes.
Signing the renewal letter without comparing offers is the easy option, and over a five-year term it can cost you. Check whether your lender plans to renew automatically, since the renewal statement has to say so. My Alberta mortgage renewal page sets out what to have ready and when to start.
At maturity, renewal and refinancing both avoid a prepayment penalty, so the cost gap is mostly fees. Mid-term it's different: breaking a closed mortgage early normally triggers a penalty, and on a fixed rate that can run to thousands of dollars.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says the penalty is usually the higher of three months' interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), and the IRD usually applies when your rate is above today's rate. Your contract decides whether the IRD starts from the posted rate when you signed or from your discounted rate, so penalties on one balance can differ widely. Your lender must explain its method, says FCAC's guide to prepayment penalties.
Ask your lender for a written penalty quote before you compare refinance offers, and ask which rate it used for the IRD. Then you can set the penalty against the interest you'd actually save.
The numbers can still work when the refinance replaces expensive debt. In this illustrative example, using assumed rates rather than today's, someone carries $40,000 on credit cards at 20% and could refinance it at 4%:
Many variable-rate contracts set the penalty at three months' interest, which is easier to estimate than an IRD. Check your own contract, since the terms are set by your lender rather than by a provincial rule.
If the penalty is the sticking point, compare it with what a full Alberta refinance would let you change, or ask whether your lender will extend your term early. FCAC notes that some lenders allow this without a prepayment penalty, though administrative fees may apply.
Choose renewal if your term ends within the next few months and you don't need to restructure your debt or take out equity. Choose refinancing if you need to borrow against the house, consolidate expensive debt, buy out a co-owner or change your amortization, and the numbers still work after costs.
Your term is ending and the renewal offer is higher than the rate you've had. That's a renewal decision, not a refinance: compare offers from other lenders before you sign, because an uninsured straight switch to another federally regulated lender doesn't have to pass the stress test if the amount and amortization stay the same, according to OSFI. With access to 40+ lenders, I can line up competing offers against your renewal letter.
You've built equity in your Calgary or Edmonton home, but you're also carrying a vehicle loan, a line of credit and credit card balances at higher rates, and you're partway through a five-year fixed term. This is where a mid-term refinance can make sense, if the interest saved beats the penalty and fees. Compare it with the other route in my guide to a debt consolidation mortgage vs a personal loan before you decide.
You own a hobby farm or acreage near Olds or Ponoka and want a new rate, maybe with some equity for outbuilding repairs. Renewing with your current lender keeps things simple, but a switch or a refinance means the new lender reviews the property, and lenders don't all finance acreages on the same terms. I specialize in rural financing, including acreages, hobby farms, wells and septic, so I can match the property to lenders that work with it.
Buying out a co-owner after a separation means putting the mortgage in one name and paying out the other person's share, so it's a refinance or a new mortgage, wherever you are in your term. The steps are in my guide to a spousal buyout mortgage in Alberta.
Start with the end date on your current mortgage. If your term ends within the next few months, gather your renewal statement and a penalty quote, and decide whether you need equity out or just a better rate.
A free mortgage review puts your renewal offer, the penalty and any refinance option side by side before you commit. My services are free to borrowers because the lender pays at closing. When you're ready, send me your renewal letter and I'll compare it with what other lenders offer.